SCUTTLEBUTT 1260 - February 12, 2003
Powered by SAIC (www.saic.com), an employee-owned company. Scuttlebutt is a
digest of major yacht racing news, commentary, opinions, features and dock
talk . . . with a North American emphasis. Corrections, contributions,
press releases, constructive criticism and contrasting viewpoints are
always welcome, but save your bashing and personal attacks for elsewhere.
ISAF WORLD SAILING CHAMPIONSHIPS - Paul Henderson
(Following are excerpts from ISAF President Paul Henderson's report on the
2003 ISAF World Sailing Championships in Cadiz, Spain.)
The ISAF ExecCom has just had a very positive tour and report on the
preparations for the ISAF Joint World Championship of Olympic Classes. This
event was initiated to become the World Cup of Sailing held every four
years to promote the sport using the Olympic Classes. I can report that the
Mundo Vela and Cadiz are doing a superb job. Laser Class will have the best
facilities all of us have ever seen. It could run the whole Olympic Games
now let alone just the Laser. 470 in Rota is also a facility with superb
launching and onshore facilities. The town is adjacent with hotels and
restaurants. Other classes are at Puerto Sherry and the area, ramps and
docks, are very large.
All courses are very close and within 15 minutes sail of the marinas. I
believe that no class has ever had better facilities. I checked on rental
accommodation and there are many choices. I was shown a 3 bedroom Condo
within 5 minutes from the marina with all ammenities and only 3 years old
for 600 EUR a week and a private house on the sea for 800 EUR.
ISAF will appoint a PRO for each course. Jury Members have been appointed
with input from the classes. It is ISAF's firm opinion that the Cadiz
Worlds will be to as high a standard as ever seen at the individual Class
Worlds. - Paul Henderson,
Event website: http://www.mundovela.com/
Robert McNeil's Maxi 86 Zephyrus V set new Pineapple Cup course record for
the 811 mile race from Port Everglades, Florida to Montego Bay, Jamaica.
Their time of 2 days, 23 hours, 5 minutes and 57 took 4 hours, 34 minutes
and 10 seconds off of the long standing record of set in 1971 by Windward
Passage. - http://www.montegobayrace.com/
(Team New Zealand Principal Designer Clay Oliver) trained as an architect
at the US Naval Academy in Annapolis where his focus was mostly on
warships. After leaving the navy, he joined an architecture company based
in Annapolis, concentrating on defence and military applications. He then
worked for the US defence contracting company, SAIC. It was through that
company he became involved with the America's Cup.
"SAIC said they had this small project with the America's Cup that I could
work on. They said it might be four weeks, or four months, but it turned
into three years, mostly assigned to Dennis Conner's campaign in
Australia." Conner regained the trophy in 1987 and when New Zealand's Sir
Michael Fay challenged in 1988, Clay worked on Conner's catamaran. He then
teamed up with designer Bruce Farr and worked on the 1992 New Zealand
Challenge and Chris Dickson's 1995 Tag Heuer.
Oliver joined Team New Zealand for the 2000 cup and opted to stay with the
syndicate for their second defense. And when Team NZ's black boats were
unveiled, hull appendages and all, before the challenger series final,
Oliver and his design team became the talk of the town. - From a story by
Julie Ash on the NZ Herald website, full story:
To learn more about Clay Oliver's work and thoughts on the 'Hula':
INTERESTED IN SAVING WEIGHT?
If your mechanical vang is old or heavy, take a look at Hall Spars &
Rigging's QuikVang 2000. The QuikVang 2000 is effortless to use, and
incredibly lightweight. The secret is its pneumatic cylinder design. Return
force is generated by compressed air; adjusting the vang force to match the
weight of your boom is as simple as pumping up a bicycle tire. And it's
easy to install on any boat: read our instruction manual online. For the
month of February, use the magic word SCUTTLEBUTT2 in our online coupon and
save an additional 5% on the purchase of a QuikVang 2000.
JULES VERNE TROPHY
* GERONIMO: In the 24 hours to 03:00 GMT today, the Cap Gemini and
Schneider Electric trimaran covered 504 nautical miles at an average speed
of 21.04 knots. The Indian Ocean is now just a memory and its hostile seas
and leaden skies forgotten as everyone looks forward to the beauty of the
Pacific. - http://www.grandsrecords.com
* KINGFISHER2 starts a gradual move east whilst still maintaining a push
south averaging 7 knots. The wind has started to move to the left and gives
Kingfisher2 the chance to start making some Easting gain - in the right
direction. Shore-based weather router, Meeno Schrader advised Ellen: "Take
the chance to shorten the course and keep some pace even with the risk of
running into light airs," said Schrader.
Kingfisher2 Day 12 Summary (http://www.teamkingfisher.com):
- 12 hours 40 minutes behind Orange
- 52 hours 12 minutes behind Geronimo
- Day 12 (24 hour run): Kingfisher2- 266 nm, Orange- 252nm, Geronimo- 459nm
- Distance to go: Kingfisher2- 20496nm, Orange- 20294nm, Geronimo- 19661nm
ON THE TUBE
* February 13th at 8:00 PM ET/PT - Outdoor Life Network will broadcast
Defining Moments: The Louis Vuitton Cup, a one-hour highlight program of
the challenger series. The network's highlight program will document the
most memorable and exciting moments from the elimination series during
which nine teams from six countries descended upon Auckland, New Zealand.
Three-time Cup challenger Dawn Riley and America's Cup winner Peter Isler
join host Bill Patrick for this highlight program that will feature the
finals races between Alinghi and Oracle BMW Racing, plus the defining
moments that transpired beginning with the First Round Robin back in
October. OLN analysts will also preview the match between Alinghi and Team
New Zealand, including the unveiling from Auckland of the declared boats
that would go head-to-head - and the latest news of the off-water "war of
words" between the syndicates. - www.OLNTV.com
* Following is the schedule for ESPN2's America's Cup 2003 programs.
America's Cup 2003 Preview (1 hour)
Thursday, February 13 at 11:00pm ET (8:00pm PT)
Friday, February 14 at 12:00pm ET (9:00am PT) (reair)
America's Cup 2003
Race 1 - Friday, February 14 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 2 - Saturday, February 15 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 3 - Monday, February 17 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 4 - Wednesday, February 19 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 5 - Friday, February 21 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 6 - Saturday, February 22 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 7 - Monday, February 24 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 8 - Wednesday, February 26 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
Race 9 - Friday, February 28 at 7:00pm ET (4:00pm PT)
This is a best of nine series. http://www.jobsonsailing.com/
AROUND ALONE 2003
Canadian skipper Derek Hatfield, has informed the race office that he is
experiencing from charging problems on board his Open 40 Spirit of Canada.
Hatfield is heading back towards New Zealand shores just a day's sailing
away. He reported that each time he shut his engine down after charging, he
got a spike in power of up to 17 volts which he believes has fried all of
his onboard electronics. Either the electronics are dead, or the wiring in
the boat is dead and he can't check the electronics, but either way it's
not good. Derek suspects that an internal short in the new batteries which
he installed in New Zealand caused the problem and as a result his GPS,
autopilots and computers are not working.
STANDINGS 2200 UTC February 11 CLASS 1: 1. Bobst Group-Armor Lux, Bernard
Stamm, 6864 miles from finish; 2. Solidaires, Thierry Dubois, 7 miles
behind leader; 3. Ocean Planet, Bruce Schwab, 13 mbl; 4. Tiscali, Simone
Bianchetti, 18 mbl 5. Pindar, Emma Richards, 19 mbl 6. Hexagon, Graham
Dalton, 32 mbl.
CLASS 2: 1. Tommy Hilfiger, Brad Van Liew, 6880 miles from finish; 2.
Everest Horizontal, Tim Kent, 89 mbl; 3. Spirit of yukoh, Kojiro Shiraishi,
108 mbl; 4. BTC Velocity, Alan Paris, 133 mbl; 5. Spirit of Canada, Derek
Hatfield, 432 mbl. - www.aroundalone.com
QUOTES FROM THE DESIGNERS
* "People thought we were going to try to work in the same direction as
Team New Zealand. But we think we have been going in the right direction
all the time, so we just wanted to improve, rather than try to copy
something." - Rolf Vrolijk, Alinghi principal designer
* "These are two boats that are quite different in every respect except
for the rig. You would expect one would be faster and one would be slower,
but we just don't know." - Team New Zealand designer Mike Drummond
* "The longer bulb gets the centre of gravity lower, presumably at the
expense of some drag, so it may be faster upwind but almost certainly
slower downwind. - Oracle designer Bruce Farr
* (Re the 'Hula') "I think it is an atrocity that this has been allowed
by the measurers to get through the rules. It was never anticipated or
intended by the rules. If you look carefully through the rules there are
plenty which indicate it is not supposed to be there. - Oracle designer
* "The hula's job is actually to try to reduce the wave resistance ... If
the boat's ghosting along at three knots of boatspeed, there's no waves so
the hula's not doing anything. If you're doing 14 knots, it's doing quite a
lot." Clay Oliver, Team New Zealand designer
All quotes were taken from stories by Julie Ash and Helen Tunnah on the New
Zealand Herald website: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/americascup/
TAKE A PEEK
For those readers who could not make the boat 'unveilings' in Auckland, the
Sailing Scuttlebutt website has just posted new photos by Daniel Forster of
the both the challenger and the defender. There are fresh images of Team
New Zealand's 'Hula,' plus some keel photos of both boats. There is
certainly a huge difference between the bulbs on the two boats.
J/105 ROULETTE? - "NOT!"
Are you and your crew willing to play J/105 Roulette with your sailing
season? Whether it's racing or gambling, one fact remains the same;
successful competitors have learned to increase the odds in their favor.
Ullman Sails has consistently placed more J/105 customers at the top of
major regattas around the country then any other sailmaker. If you are
ready to stack the deck for your 2003 season, then give the Ullman Sails
loft in your area a call or visit us at http://www.ullmansails.com
WATCH FOR FLAGS
Britain's Independent yachting writer Stuart Alexander said there was a
strong possibility that the umpires would play a big role once racing
started on Saturday. "The predictions are that Alinghi may be quicker going
upwind and that Team New Zealand - with the combination of the hula and
maybe 12 square metres in extra sailing area - will be quicker downwind.
But trying to overtake a boat downwind often produces tense close-quarter
That would be when the umpires come into play. Each boat carries an
umpire-observer, who acts in an advisory capacity to the chief umpire and
those on the wing boats. Alexander said he still fancied the Kiwis to take
the cup though Alinghi had a "very smart team". - Mary Jane Boland, The
Dominion Post, full story:
* Neville Crichton's water-ballasted maxi-racer Alfa Romeo powered away
from her more stately performance cruiser sisters today to handsomely win
the corrected and elapsed time trophies for the Kawau Island Race in the
Millennium Cup Superyacht Regatta. Just five minutes and 23 seconds behind
her, Bob Miller's 146-foot ketch Mari Cha III finished in second place.
* The sixth race of the Clipper 2002 series gets underway Wednesday, 12
February 2003 at 12:00 Hawaiian Standard Time (22:00 GMT). A 3,400 nautical
mile race from Hawaii to Japan lies ahead for the Clipper fleet. The third
crew leg of Clipper 2002 covers a distance of approximately 6,000 miles,
over some seven weeks, on its way to Hong Kong via Japan and China. The
adventure starts with a fast, warm downwind sleigh ride, which can see the
yachts exceed 200 miles a day. - www.clipper-ventures.com
* French bowman Bernard Labro sustained a broken clavicle in a traffic
accident. He will not be onboard SUI 64 for the 31st America's Cup, which
begins February 15 in New Zealand. The prognosis calls for conservative
treatment and doctors expect the bone will mend completely after 6 weeks.
Bernard will not sail until then, and his left arm is immobilized in a
sling, but doctors granted permission to resume moderate activity within 3
weeks. - www.alinghi.com/en/index.php
LETTERS TO THE CURMUDGEON (firstname.lastname@example.org)
(Letters selected for publication must include the writer's name and may be
edited for clarity or space - 250 words max. This is not a chat room or a
bulletin board - you only get one letter per subject, so give it your best
shot and don't whine if others disagree.)
* From William F. Cook: I am sure that there is going to be some backlash
against Kevin Hall for his comments yesterday, and I am equally sure that
most if not all of it will be from people who don't know Kevin and who did
not have to experience the truly unfriendly atmosphere with which
competitors in America's Cup 2003 were greeted in Auckland.
This is all so unfortunate. A competition which is historically ruthless on
the water and in the jury room but (at least in recent memory) still
friendly at the bar has been converted into a truly bitter, angry circus
spectacle. We've had a disgraceful hate campaign and some less-than-genuine
rules "reforms", and now we have a legion of disillusioned fans, including
Paul Allen, Craig McCaw, and some others who, if they stayed in the game,
could really help our sport. For shame!
Let's hope that the winner of the Cup will not simply carry over the
current event structure, with its built-in controversies and distractions.
Let's hope that they will truly try to create a great event. It's a good
thing to hope for. But don't hold your breath.
* From Marty Fetsch (Re Kevin Hall's letter): It is sad to see
achievement in one area, Team Racing, used as a pulpit to vent ones
frustrations with the America's Cup. Everyone knows that TNZ is working
hard to win again and that there are disagreements about people and
equipment. The Kiwi's have earned a reputation as great sailors and in many
cases great sportsman. It is a shame that Peter Lester is not one of them.
* From Roger Jolly: Kevin Hall's letter has confirmed what I've always
suspected. The real trickle down from the Americas cup is poor
sportsmanship. And to Mr. Lester's suggestion that team racers at the World
Championships may some day be able to participate in the Americas cup if
they play their cards right. I assure you Mr. Lester that if those sailors
wanted to be racing in the Americas cup they would be. Don't assume that a
bigger boat is equal to bigger talent, at least Philippe Kahn has figured
that much out.
* From Ron Baerwitz: I wholeheartedly agree with Scott Barnard comments
about Philippe Kahn. I have never met the man but I have seen his love for
the sport blossom. Unlike many wealthy owners who pay for the program and
then let some rock star coach them around the course, Mr. Kahn has taken to
hiring top notch coaches like Mark Reynolds and Morgan Reeser to teach him
the sport. He practices, practices, practices on all types of boats and the
results are showing. Again, I have never met him but I have great respect
for a man of his stature who put his ego aside and his love for the sport
first. He appears to be a very class act.
* From Joe Lotuff: While it may be, for some, an interesting exercise to
propose modifications for future America's Cup Regattas. I respectfully
submit that we are about to experience, and should prepare to enjoy, what
will likely be one of the most exciting match racing regattas in recent
history. All the elements of intrigue and personality are present; both
teams will bring to the line sailing crews in the pink of condition, at the
highest level of skill and training. The boats, sails and rigging represent
the highest evolution of the IACC. Valentine's day at 19:00 hrs (ET) -
We've got the ball game on. The afterguards will be miked up, virtual
spectator providing the data and the big screen TV sorted and ready to go.
Are you ready for some sailing?
From Greg Weeger: I am intrigued with Alinghi's Curtis Blewett comments on
the differences of the AC boats and I hope he is not creating an escape
route for either team using boat speed issues for lack of success. I
believe the brain trust from both teams previously trained using marginally
slower boats, computer simulated or real and succeed. The only catch they
say is a perfect pre-start and no on-the-water mistakes. I would say good
luck Curtis, but as we know Luck has nothing to do with it. My suggestion,
pretend you are on the slower boat and you can't loose.
* From Chris Woods: We cannot possibly give enough congratulations to USA
2 for their well deserved win at the Team Racing Worlds in NZ last week,
and for what they represent in the sport of sailing. Timothy Fallon, Karen
Renzulli, Graeme & Lee Woodworth, Brian Doyle and Ery Largay (along with
coach Kevin Hall and others) showed not only the top skills at an event
which is in many ways the summit of the sport, but for years they have been
at the forefront of a unique movement in sailing.
They, along with many others across the country, have been developing team
racing as an expression of what we might call sailing's best "character".
This is a group of excellent sailors and fierce competitors, who like
nothing more than to help their fellow sailors get better. While team
racers spend long days competing on the water (399 races in 6 days at the
2003 World's), no one keener on spending time afterwards helping others
figure out rules and showing others how to improve their tactics. And while
much has been said about Team USA 2's winning the silver at 5 major
regattas, you can't recognize enough that this crew is the first to
genuinely praise and appreciate the winners.
Team USA 2 and others are building an enviable model for the sport by
following the maxim: "a rising tide lifts all boats". Because of these
efforts, not only did they win but the sailing wins.
THE CURMUDGEON'S OBSERVATION
Show me a piano falling down a mine shaft, and I'll show you A flat minor.