SCUTTLEBUTT 1246 - January 23, 2003
Powered by SAIC (www.saic.com), an employee-owned company. Scuttlebutt is a
digest of major yacht racing news, commentary, opinions, features and dock
talk . . . with a North American emphasis. Corrections, contributions,
press releases, constructive criticism and contrasting viewpoints are
always welcome, but save your bashing and personal attacks for elsewhere.
(The Yachts and Yachting website has posted a blockbuster interview done by
Magnus Wheatley with Brad Butterworth. Butterworth candidly discussed many
aspects of the Alinghi campaign, including the real reasons why he, Coutts
and the others left Team New Zealand. Here's a small excerpt from this
Magnus Wheatley: Let's go on to the controversy about you leaving TNZ…You
guys are the best sailors in the world, even if I look at the top estimates
the sums are laughable compared with top-flight American sports for
instance. Did you go for the money? Are you guys underpaid?
Brad Butterworth: Yes…Let's set the story straight we never left for the
money. Russell and I worked for three years, and a little later on Tom
Schnackenberg as well, to have a seamless transition between the management
and the owners of the team from 95-00 to a new management organization for
2003. We actually worked on for several months after the Cup was won, the
problem was that the owners and the sponsors never wanted us to carry on
with it. Peter Blake had moved on…
MW: Hold on you're saying that there are owners of TNZ - who are they?
BB: John Lusk, Tom Clarke, Jim Hoare, Roger France, Richard Green. They
weren't the trustees, they owned it along with the sponsors that were there
MW: And why didn't they want you there?
BB: I don't know. They made it impossible for us to carry on and we worked
for three years to sort this out because we knew that if we won in 2000
we'd have a lot of problems funding the thing this time and also keeping a
team. We couldn't wait a year and then say to these guys 'come on let's do
it again' as they (the crew) were all getting job offers before the Cup
started. So the night of winning in 2000 should have been one of the best
times of my life but I was actually bitterly disappointed at the attitude
of these guys that had made it impossible for us to carry on. So I could
see the whole thing falling apart. So it's just a lie that we went for the
money. It's a lie that we were the first to leave, we were the last to leave.
MW: You and Russell have often said that when the whole story comes out
everyone will understand. Is this the whole story?
BB: It's so complicated, the whole story is three years and Russell wants
to take his own timing to do this so that we do the right thing by the last
team that we were with. At that time it wasn't going to work for us and we
just wanted to move on although we still have quite an affection for the
team that we won twice with.
MW: It all became clear after that? You say the day that you won was a
disappointing day, was it all clear then?
BB: It was a disappointing day because most of the crew were taking offers
from other syndicates and we were powerless, because we weren't the owners,
to do anything. We were just two sailors in that team. - Yachts and
Yachting website, full interview:
Melges 24 leader Bruce Ayres had to return from an OCS and finished in
21st-place, which opened the door for defending champion Flavio Favini to
slide into first place of the Terra Nova Trading Key West 2003 with a
fourth place finish. Favini is now four points ahead of Ayres' Newport
Beach, Calif. colleague Argyle Campbell, with Ayres another 10 points back.
Favini blitzed the fleet last year when the prize was the delayed 2001
class Worlds title, but he hadn't sailed a Melges since while participating
in the America's Cup.
Wind shifts - including one of 100 degrees - shuffled the fleet. While the
Division 1, 3 and 4 courses managed one race, the biggest boats on Division
2 called it a day when the wind swung so far, principal race officer Bruce
Golison said, that "there was no way to get a finish line [placed] due to
the rocks." That left Rosebud, Roger Sturgeon's Transpac 52 from San
Francisco, in command of PHRF 1 ahead of Bill Alcott's Andrews 70
turbosled, Equation, from Detroit.
The Farr 40s remained muddled as George Andreadis' Atalanti XII (Robbie
Haines on tactics) from Greece and the Scott Harris/Alexandra Geremia
Crocodile Rock (Vince Brun), Santa Barbara, swapped spots on the
leaderboard. John Kilroy's Samba Pa Ti (Paul Cayard), appeared to be
running away until the monster shift kicked it back to seventh place.
Atalanti XII struggled from the start and was recovering nicely until the
shift dumped it into 15th place in the race and second in the regatta, two
points behind Crocodile Rock.
The day's Farr 40 winner? Stuart Townsend's Virago (Steve Benjamin) from
Chicago finished first, but opted for a 20% alternative penalty on the
water rather than risk a DSQ on a protest by Alex Krstajic's Honour (Tony
Rey), which claimed leeward rights at the start. That made John
Coumantaros' Bambakou (Chris Larson) the day's low scorer in second place,
although still in mid-fleet overall.
There is only one unbeaten boat remaining---Mike Carroll's Henderson 30,
New Wave, with four wins in PHRF 4, which was unable to race Wednesday.
Thursday's weather forecast looks gnarly. It calls for ideal breeze to 15
knots in the morning followed by a cold front bringing a sustained blow of
20-25 knots in the early afternoon when the second race should be under
way. - Rich Roberts, Complete results at www.Premiere-Racing.com
CARBON SAILS? YOU NEED PROGEN II
Progen II is the ultimate performance line. This ultra-high strength PBO
line has very low stretch and is perfect for halyards connected to carbon
sails. These sails put a lot of stress on the halyards and, as Scott Easom
of Easom Racing and Rigging says, "... we can set the halyards at their
marks and that is where they stay...." Look around the docks at Key West;
if you see boats with black covered halyards pay attention, they are the
Tauranga, New Zealand - 22 January - American skipper Tim Kent on Open 50
Everest Horizontal came smoking across the line in second place at 02:09:04
hrs local time (13:09:04 GMT) The inside of Tim's boat was painted thick
black from the engine fumes, which had leaked uncontrollably during most of
his leg. Kent has now established himself in second place overall behind
Class 2 leader Brad Van Liew on Tommy Hilfiger Freedom America after three
legs out of five. Canadian Derek Hatfield on Open 40 Spirit of Canada has
been his nemesis since the very start of the race, and they were on equal
points starting this leg from Cape Town.
Shortly before lunch the Canadian flag could be seen snapping in the wind
as Derek Hatfield sailed Spirit of Canada towards the finish line. His
official finish time was 12:10:06 local time (23:10:06 GMT on Wednesday).
Sailing one of the smallest boats in the fleet, Derek has pushed and
coerced every inch of performance from his boat at times threatening
Everest Horizontal ahead of him. - www.aroundalone.com
KEY WEST SIDE BAR
It was clear that the race committee had its hands full on Wednesday, but
the sailors seemed satisfied that the difficulties were handled as well as
possible. Gavin Brady, the tactician on Jim Richardson's Barking Mad,
Newport, R.I., has raced in the top level all over the world and had high
praise for Division 1 PRO Ken Legler, although he didn't know his name.
"The race committee guy on that course is the best I've ever seen," Brady
said. "He doesn't make it a mystery for the competitors. He talks to us [by
radio] and lets us know what's going on: 'Hey, guys, I'm only going to do
one race today . . .' He needs to write the book on how to run a race
committee." - Rich Roberts
(The Daily Sail talked with K-Yachting's visionary boss Stéphane Kandler,
about his 2006 America's Cup campaign to be headed by Dawn Riley. Here's a
brief excerpt from that story.)
An obvious man to get behind the drawing board is Juan Kouyoumdjian. "Yes
we have a long history with Juan but for sure we will try and attract
people who have the same philosophy," says Kandler.
Personnel-wise aside from Dawn Riley, top French match racer Thierry
Peponnet is on board and Nicholas Charbonnier, who has already proved
himself on the junior match racing stage, is also likely to be involved.
"Bertrand Pace, we have a very good relationship with him. We think he is a
very strong guy," says Kandler. "He is one of the best in the world, but in
France nobody knew him before he started to sail with Team New Zealand.
"After that we want to have a very good architect who has a good view of
the America's Cup boats, who has a good view of the America's Cup boats and
Dawn has many many relationships so we hope to get some people who are
involved now in other campaigns, so it is difficult to say who will be
there." No firm decisions on personnel will be made until the Cup is over
at the end of February. - The Daily Sail website, full story:
Last America's Cup it was the red socks campaign. Now Team New Zealand has
embarked on a new campaign: $10 "loyal" car aerial flags. The famous socks,
used as a tool to raise funds and national pride during the past two
regattas, are not being sold this Cup after the murder of syndicate head
Sir Peter Blake.
* But a public fundraising campaign has begun, with the sale of "loyal"
flags which are part of Team New Zealand's advertising campaign promoting
key crew who stayed with the team, turning down lucrative contracts with
foreign syndicates. The sale of the flags, which fit on to car aerials and
cost $10, was announced a day after the Swiss team Alinghi, brimming with
New Zealand talent, won the right to challenge Team New Zealand for the Cup
next month. Half the proceeds from the sales will go to Team New Zealand.
The rest of the money will cover manufacturing costs.
Team New Zealand's budget is estimated at about $80 million, while
Alinghi's is thought to be US$70 million ($127.7 million). Helen Tunnah, NZ
Herald, full story:
MORE KEY WEST
Essential gear for a regatta this big includes: boat, wind, crew, beer and
another t-shirt. The Pirate's Lair provides the best graphics, tees, polos,
fleece and caps for the sailing world. The Pirate's Lair is also the
official supplier for merchandise at Key West Race Week. For a free catalog
and widget, call them at (888) SAIL-BUM or log on at
The Midwest Collegiate Sailing Association will be leading a casual panel
presentation on College Sailing at Strictly Sail Chicago at Navy Pier on
Saturday, February 1, 2003, at 3:00 p.m. Central Time. Youth and junior
sailors, parents, coaches, The program is geared to Junior Program
Directors, current college students or staff wanting to start a club/ team,
alumni, and anyone interested in what college sailing has to offer. The
MCSA will have a small table at the Harken booth at the show all four days.
QUOTE / UNQUOTE - Dennis Conner
"It's sad not to have the U.S. in the final but hopefully we'll see Larry
(Ellison) back. It's in my blood but talk's cheap and I have to go and
raise the money. Until I have it I can't really raise my hand." - Fox
Sports website, http://foxsports.lycos.com/content/view?contentId=865680
LETTERS TO THE CURMUDGEON (email@example.com)
(Letters selected for publication must include the writer's name and may be
edited for clarity or space - 250 words max. This is not a chat room or a
bulletin board - you only get one letter per subject, so give it your best
shot and don't whine if others disagree.)
* From Peter Huston: One of the unique - maybe bizarre - things about the
America's Cup is the time honored tradition of a Commodore from a
pre-selected club handing a challenge to the Commodore of the Cup winning
club as the first boat crosses the finish line in the last race. This year
will be no different, but with the current structure of the Cup which leads
to an unreasonable business equation, who would want the hassle that comes
with being the Challenger of Record?
Perhaps more interesting will be watching lawyers hired by billionaire team
owners leap off of team tenders and on to TNZ after the last Cup race,
while heaving bags of cash towards Dean Barker and crew in an attempt to
acquire their services for the next Cup. Clay Oliver will no doubt be
swarmed by shoreside team agents, again, with wads of cash being thrust at
him. The only question now is whether an American ex-pat like Oliver will
take the money and run, and whether or not young Dean understands the
economic principle behind the present value of money. Now that we have
determined what you are boys, we are just talking about the price, because
all loyalty programs aside, you are being paid by TNZ aren't you? Before
signing up with TNZ again for chump wages, why not ask your banker if they
will accept your loyalty to New Zealand as collateral for house, car or
college education for your children. Does loyalty equal chump?
* From Steve Wells: I wonder if most people feel as I do, the AC is now
between the rich NZ crew (Swiss) and the poor NZ crew (local). Or as some
have suggested the morally correct vs. the immoral rich. Anyway, the AC is
now just a local Auckland race now as far as I'm concerned.
Is there a place to get a good picture of the offending appendage? I can't
really understand anyone's explanation and I haven't seen any really good
CURMUDGEON'S COMMENT: Daniel Forster has several excellent photos of the
Kiwi appendage on his website: http://www.yachtphoto.com/skirtsaway03.html
* From Michael Leneman: The critique of multihulls usually comes from
those who have never sailed on them. To call them only marginally faster
than the monohulls is to mis-represent their speed, and to call them "not
real boats" is to revel in the prejudices of the last four decades. Sail on
them, watch them, and experience their thrill. No one freaked out when a
number of open 60's (monohulls) went upside down and stayed there on
previous 'round the world races. They just made them safer, and that's what
the Formula 60's gang will do as well.
* From Steve Greene: With regards to comments on monohull vs. multihull
and what is or isn't a "real boat" (Butt 1245), I would submit that
Polynesian proas were making safe ocean voyages long before the monohulls
of European explorers hit the seas. My sailing background includes Snark,
Laser, Force 5, Hobie, Stowaway 15, Ensign, International 500, WindRider,
Sweet 16 and many others. Next I might try Scows. I hear they are a blast,
though my own bigotry says a scow isn't a real boat because real boats
should have pointy bows! But I understand that a squared bow is what
defines a scow, just as multiple hulls define a multihull.
There will always be a divide between factions with regard to boat
preference, but there is room for growth, understanding and acceptance.
Agreed, the last Route du Rhum was rough on the multihull fleet, but no
more so than the Sidney/ Hobart was on the monohull fleet a few years ago
which ended in serious loss of life! No one perished in the Route du Rhum.
The Sidney/ Hobart tragedy led to big changes in safety protocol, boat
design, and manufacturing- all for the better just as the last Rhum will
surely lead to innovations in multihulls.
Overall, if multihulls are good enough for Ellen MacArthur, they are good
enough for me! Um, excuse me Ms. Mac Arthur, you aren't sailing a real
boat? Give me a break! If a multihull isn't a real boat, I don't know what is.
* From Tony Hammer: So Phil Olbert would hate to see multihulls in the
Volvo Round the World because there not "real boats" and go too fast. He
must be rather disappointed that the Americas Cup boats aren't still gaff
rigged. And Gad!, The crew aren't wearing white flannel pants either! He's
right about last year's Route du Rum though, it was a fiasco, but that was
mainly because the boats were single-handed.
* From Dick Katz: Everyone's moaning and groaning about team New
Zealand's so called "hula" appendage - well - it's been tested and measured
and declared fast AND legal...just like the "knuckle" bow was...so we must
live with it... I for one, would like to see some input as to their radical
bulb design - this thing is long and sleek and would seem to help balance
the boat fore and aft which would mean less time moving up and down in the
waves and more time sailing in a straight line.
* From Kyle Clark: I remember growing up sailing Sabots as a kid and the
first time I ever was exposed to video-taped races. We were racing in
Alamitos Bay and someone's dad brought a camera to tape the regatta.
Saturday night all the sailors and families gathered around a TV set
upstairs in the clubhouse to watch the action. Half-way through the first
weather-mark rounding one of the fathers ran to the TV and turned off the
sound because of all the foul language ... mostly high-piched obsceneties
from the girls!
CURMUDGEON'S COMMENT: Let it be known that Kyle has had the last word. This
thread is now officially dead.
THE CURMUDGEON'S CONUNDRUMS
Why do we play in recitals and recite in plays?