SCUTTLEBUTT #260 - January 19, 1999
FOX Sports Net, a division of FOX Television, has signed a major cash
sponsorship agreement with the NYYC/Young America Challenge for America's
Cup. FOX Sports Net is Young America's first Premier Partner, the top-level
"The partnership with FOX is a significant milestone in our fundraising
campaign, said John Marshall, president of the NYYC/Young America
Challenge. "It is particularly important that this is a cash sponsorship.
FOX's help provides us the funding to build two new International America's
Cup Class yachts this winter for the 2000 competition. With construction of
our first boat starting in the next few weeks, the FOX partnership is
keeping us on track."
The sponsorship package includes extensive corporate hospitality both in
Newport, RI, starting in the summer of 1999 and in Auckland, New Zealand
beginning with the Challenger Races for the Louis Vuitton Cup which start
in October, 1999. Other sponsor benefits include logo signage on Young
America's sails and the hulls of the two new racing boats as well as
signage at all Young America venues, and in Young America communications
such as the newsletter and web site. FOX also receives a number of 17th
crew member positions, the unique opportunity to sail on the racing boat
"In October, our sailing team became the first of the now 15 Challengers to
conduct two-boat testing and training on the America's Cup race course in
Auckland, New Zealand. Our design/technology team is seeing exciting
results from more than two years of two-boat testing and laboratory
research and development, and construction is about to begin on the first
of our two America's Cup boats," Marshall said. "We have now raised some
$24 million, more than 60 percent of our total budget. The first race for
the Louis Vuitton Cup is exactly nine months from today and thanks to this
support, we are exactly where we want to be." -- Jane Eagleson
Young America website: http://www.youngamerica.org
KWRW - Report by Sean McNeill
Two one-design classes got a head start in the race for the Yachting
Magazine Trophy, awarded to the overall Boat of the Week at GMC Yukon
Yachting Key West Race Week, as competition began today at the
international keelboat regatta held on the Straits of Florida off Key West.
Conquering a puffy and shifty breeze blowing between 6 and 10 knots from
the southeast, the 1D35 and Farr 40 classes were the finalists for Race
Week 99's first Boat of the Day award. The award is determined using a time
and distance formula. A smaller ratio indicates a more competitive class.
The time and distance formula is one of two criteria used to determine the
Yachting Magazine Trophy winner.
At the end of the day, the duo of Johnny Roberts and Ed McMurphy, co-owners
of the 1D35 Fine Line, claimed the daily honor and with it a titanium MR-G
Tactician watch from event sponsor and sponsor of the day Casio Watches.
First through fifth in the class was separated by 2 minutes and 3 seconds.
"Today it was a matter of where you went," said Roberts, referring to the
challenging conditions that foiled the winning hopes of many early race
leaders. "I just went where my tactician, Bill Fortenberry, told me to go.
The pressure's now on to keep it going all week."
The Farr 40 class finished runner-up for the award. John Thomson (Port
Washington, N.Y.) drove his defending class champion Solution to a
29-second victory over Jack Woodhull's (Newport Beach, Calif.) Persephone.
First through fifth in the class was separated by 2 minutes and 12 seconds.
"The one-designs always provide close racing," said Event Director Peter
Craig. "Success today didn't come easy. The breeze was puffy and there were
some major shifts, which makes the performance of these classes even more
Other class winners relied on the large wind shifts to fight their way into
the winner's circle. Pasquale Landolfi's (Porto Cervo, Italy) Brava Q8 won
IMS 2 in such fashion. Brava Q8, a 40-footer, trailed a few of its rivals
around the first leeward mark, and then banged the left side of the second
beat and shot into the lead. Brava Q8, a two-time ILC 40 World Champion,
won the class by more than four and a half minutes.
Paolo Gaia's (Milan, Italy) 49-footer Breeze won IMS 1 in similar dominant
fashion. Breeze finished third at Race Week '98, and is looking to rebound
from that showing. "We're very happy with our performance today," said
Gaia. "We did very well among the 50-footers in Europe last summer, and
we're looking to continue that streak here this year."
In the Melges 24 class, which is hosting its Midwinter Championship in
conjunction with Race Week, Charlie Ogletree's (Newport Beach, Calif.)
Planet Loaf finished first and second and opened an early 4-point lead over
Bruce Ayres' (Newport Beach, Calif.) Monsoon, which won Race 1 but finished
6th in Race 2. Brian Porter's (Lake Geneva, Ill.) Full Throttle holds third
after Day 1 with finishes of 7-2.
The Mumm 30 class began its '99 season with Massimo Mezzaroma's (Rome,
Italy) Malinda/Invicta capturing the early lead. Malinda/Invicta placed 2-4
in today's racing, good for a 1 point lead over Bodo Von der Wense's
(Annapolis, Md.) Turbo Duck and Carla Silva's (Portofino, Italy) Sector.
Steve Liebel's (Sarasota, Fla.) Speedracer blitzed the competition in the
Henderson 30 class with two firsts, winning Race 1 by 1 minute, 17 seconds,
and Race 2 by 2 minutes, 42 seconds. Michael Carroll's (Clearwater, Fla.)
New Wave and James Walsh and David Cook's (Brielle, N.J.) Purple Haze are
tied for second. Each had a 2nd- and 3rd-place finish today.
Italy's strong showing in IMS 1 and the Mumm 30 class helped propel its
three-boat team to the early lead in the three-boat team competition for
the Yukon Cup, presented by title sponsor GMC Yukon. Team Italy (Breeze,
Malinda/Invicta, Planet Loaf) leads Team Germany (Rubin XV, Rainbow and
Monsoon) by 10 points, with the United Kingdom team (Hi Fling, Turbo Duck
and Snickers Workwear) another 6 points in arrears.
DIVISION I STANDINGS (provisional after 1 race) -- CLASS A -- IMS1 1.
Breeze/Paolo Gaia (Milan, Italy) 1, 2. Hi Fling/Irvine Laidlaw (Isle of
Man, England) 2, 3. Rubin XV/Hans-Otto Schumann (Hamburg, Germany) 3. CLASS
B -- IMS2 1. Brava Q8/Pasquale Landolfi (Porto Cervo, Italy) 1, 2.
Hawk/Nigel Bramwell (Hamble, England) 2, 3. Heatwave/Sal Giordano
(Edgartown, MA) 3. CLASS C -- Farr 40 1. Solution/John Thomson (Port
Washington, NY) 1, 2. Persephone/J.R. Woodhull (Newport Beach, CA) 2, 3.
Passage/B.Jayson & B.Burgess (Newport, RI) 3. CLASS D -- PHRF1 1.
Starlight/Jay Ecklund (Ft. Lauderdale, FL) 1, 2. Elyxir/Paul Ely (Santa
Cruz, CA) 2, 3. Fatal Attraction/F. Gray Kiger (Farr 39ML) 3. CLASS E --
1D35 1. Fine Line/J. Roberts & E. McMurphy (Ono Island, AL) 1, 2. Northern
Bear/Stephan Pfeifer (Milwaukee, WI), 3. Windquest/Doug DeVos (Holland, MI)
3. CLASS F -- PHRF2 1. Wai Rere/Chris Bouzaid (Jamestown, RI) 1, 2. Letter
of Marque/W. Colahan & D. Halsted (Marblehead, MA) 2, 3. Full
Circle/Sanford Richardson (Hampton, VA) 3. CLASS G -- PHRF3 1.
Fitikoko/Andrew Wilson (Annapolis, MD) 1, 2. No Fear/Kjell Jacobsson
(Sweden) 2, 3. Lunatic Fringe/Eric Wynsma (Grand Rapids, MI) 3.
DIVISION 2 STANDINGS (provisional after 2 races) -- CLASS A - PHRF 4 1.
Surprise/Joan Tryzelaar (Portland, ME) 1-1--2, 2. Snake Eyes/Tom Ballard
(Annapolis, MD) 2-2--4, 3. Wild Thang/Thomas Podgorski (Grosse Pointe, MI)
3-4--7. CLASS B1 - Viper 830 1. RE/Guy de Boer (Detroit, MI) 1-2--3, 2.
Extreme Measures/Doug Harkrider (Flowery Banch, GA) 3-1--4, 3. Impulsive
Response/Ted Balfour (Randolph, NJ) 2-3--5. CLASS B2 - J/105 1. Southern
Crescent/Daniel Kerckhoff (Naples, FL) 2-3--5, 2. Phenix/Bob Swirbalus
(Boston, MA) 3-2--5, 3. Hi-Jinx/Tom Thayer (Jamestown, RI) 1-5--6. CLASS C
- J/29 1. Dirty Harry/John Lavin (E. Greenwich, RI) 2-3--5, 2. WOW/W. Rojek
& A. Zaleski (City Island, NY) 1-5--6, 3. Hustler/John Esposito (City
Island, NY) 5-2--7. CLASS D - J/80 1. Monster Lady/Martin Kald (Pt.
Washington, NY) 4-2--6, 2. Hustle/Tim McAdams (E. Greenwich, RI) 2-5--7, 3.
Adrenalin/Gregg Morash (Newport, RI) 6-1--7. CLASS E - PHRF 5 1.
Claddagh/L. Fallon & J. Flanagan (Marblehead, MA) 1-2--3, 2. Storm
Front/James Wells (Evansville, IN) 2-1--3, 3. Think Blue/Gary Disbrow
(Vermilion, OH) 3-3--6. CLASS F - PHRF 6 1. Synchronicity/Michael Phelan
(Coconut Grove, FL) 1-2--3, 2. Creola/Jack Cavalier (Tampa, FL) 3-1--4, 3.
Hasl Free/Rudolph Hasl (Douglastown, NY) 2-3--5. CLASS G - PHRF 7 1.
Fourtune Cookie/Peter De Beukelaer (Jackson, MS) 1-2--3, 2. Fluffy
Flanks/Barry Parkoff (San Antonio, TX) 2-1--3, 3. Hot Sheet/Mitch Hnatt
(Brick, NJ) 3-3--6.
DIVISION 3 STANDINGS (provisional after 2 races) -- CLASS A - Henderson 30
1. Speedracer/Steve Liebel (Sarasota, FL) 1-1--2, 2. New Wave/Michael
Carroll (Clearwater, FL) 2-3--5, 3. Purple Haze/J. Walsh & D. Cook
(Brielle, NJ) 3-2--5. CLASS B - Mumm 30 1. Malinda/Invicta/Massimo
Mezzaroma (Rome, Italy) 2-4--6, 2. Turbo Duck/Bodo Von Der Wense
(Annapolis, MD) 6-1--7, 3. Sector/Carla Silva (Portofino, Italy) 4-3--7.
CLASS C - Melges 24 1. Planet Loaf/Charlie Ogletree (Newport Beach, CA)
2-1--3, 2. Monsoon/Bruce Ayres (Newport Beach, CA) 1-6--7, 3. Full
Throttle/Brian Porter (Lake Geneva, IL) 7-2--9.
A total of eight races are scheduled for GMC Yukon Yachting Key West Race
Week. A complete set of provisional results and scratch sheet can be found
on Race Week's web page at: http://www.yachtingnet.com
CYCA Commodore Hugo van Kretschmar, announced at a press conference that it
would be several months before the 1998 Sydney Hobart Race Review
Committee's work would be completed and findings announced. "While we are
moving as fast as we can, thoroughness, not speed is what's important now,"
he said. "We are working closely with the Coroner and respecting his wishes
and keeping the details of our Review confidential". "In the fullness of
time our finding and recommendations will be a matter of public record, but
until that time it is critical that the Committee get on with the job".
Mr van Kretschmar dismissed suggestions that the Club would not conduct an
objective review on the basis all yachties have a vested interest in the
outcome. "Our only interest is to reduce risk and improve safety for not
only ocean racing but also every single person who ventures to sea in a
boat," he said. The Committee has already established a Frame of Reference
and issued an initial Questionnaire to the 1998 Sydney-Hobart Race fleet.
The Frame of Reference includes: Race Background, Weather, Communications,
The ability of yachts and equipment to withstand the conditions, The
ability of Skippers and Crews to withstand the conditions, and Search and
It is expected to be some weeks before these questionnaires are completed
and the results tabled to provide the Committee with a detailed
understanding of exactly what the issues are. "Some aspects of our Review
are self evident, and we are addressing them immediately, others are not
and will only become clear from the results of the questionnaire and review
submissions from other interested parties," Mr van Kretschmar said. E-mail
When W.L. Gore introduced GORE-TEX fabric Ocean Technology garments in
1994, they ushered in a new level of comfort and protection to foul weather
gear. Currently, five manufacturers worldwide are licensed to produce Ocean
Technology garments. However, when the Gore Factory Management Evaluations
were issued, the highest rating, #1, went to Douglas Gill. And Gill is the
ONLY manufacturer to achieve a "1" rating. Do yourself a favor and check
out Gill's complete line of quality foul weather gear:
On January 29, the winners of the 1999 Boat of the Year (BOTY) Awards-the
"Academy Awards" of sailboat design and construction, presented annually by
Sailing World and Cruising World magazines-will be revealed at an evening
gala at the School at the Chicago Institute of Art. The BOTY Award
presentation-an invitation-only event with television personality Gary
Jobson as master of ceremonies-takes place during the Strictly Sail -
Chicago boatshow, an all-sail show held January 28-31 at Chicago's Navy Pier.
Beginning in September, a panel of judges stepped aboard some sixty boats
from 7.5 to 80-plus feet for sea trials and dockside inspections to cull
out the outstanding designs of the year. "Each year, our judges conduct
in-depth inspections and sea trials, looking for the most exemplary boats
introduced this season," says Bernadette Bernon, editorial director of The
Sailing Company. "
The 1998 BOTY overall winners were the Farr 40 One Design (Overall
Performance Boat of the Year and the Dehler 41 DS (Overall Cruising Boat
of the Year). The 1999 BOTY winners will be featured in the March issues of
Sailing World and Cruising World magazines. -- Cynthia Flanagan Goss
LETTERS TO THE CURMUDGEON
Letters may be edited for clarity, space (250 words max) or to exclude
-- From Jim Marta, Seattle -- Being a veteran of eight 2,000 mile+ ocean
races as both crew and skipper I have an interest in the
PFD/Harness/personal strobe light discussion. Any skipper or crew that
does not wear all three at night, or the first two in breezy daylight
conditions is just plain stupid! A great fear of mine has always been that
of going overboard at sea...in daylight! One is out of sight within two
minutes if any sea is running. At night, I'm sure one could take a
spinnaker down and find an overboard crew if you're within three miles,
even in very windy conditions. The strobe gives a great halo effect at
sea, particularly the airforce rescue type (only the size of a cigarette
package). In gale or storm conditions the above should always hold true if
common sense prevails. The key is to get gear on early...not after the
fact. This is a no-brainer that always hold true.
-- From Ken Redler -- I always find it interesting that nobody argues
against using a pfd and harness in stormy conditions, but they do argue at
great length about using them in light weather. They claim that the life
saving devices are a nuisance when conditions don't warrant them. Does
this mean that these devices are not a nuisance in stormy conditions? I
wear my life jacket every time I race my Snipe. The reason being that if I
get used to wearing it in calm weather, then I won't notice it when the
weather gets rough (which is when I need to be my most agile). It just
seems to me that the time to get used to wearing life saving devices while
doing sail changes at night should be in calm weather, not when the winds
are over 20 knots and the seas are washing over the deck.
-- From Charlie Arms -- I am ultimately responsible for my safety, that
means wearing a PFD when it is prudent, putting on a harness on when I feel
there is a distinct possibility of falling overboard, making sure there is
adequate safety gear on board or bringing my own, and choosing to sail with
a skipper that I trust to make the right decisions about whether or not to
keep racing. I assume the risk for participating in a sport that can be
dangerous. It is not like we are shanghaied, we choose to sail and anyone
who trie to place responsibility for their wellbeing on anyone but
themselves ought to take up another sport, perhaps knitting.
-- William Henderson -- Tom Ehman, you could not have summed up the
problems at US Sailing better or in less words if your life had depended on
it. It was eloquent. Not only did you demonstrate more clearly than anyone
else what is wrong with this whole PFD thing, you pin-pointed the
underlying problem and the solution.
As long as we have people at US Sailing making arbitrary and capricious
decisions based on their idea of what the world should be like instead of
genuinely soliciting opinions and input from the members we will continue
to have disasters like the PFD decision.
Their whole arguement is based on the premise of, "If it saves one life,
it's all worth it." If saving lives is your goal, then STAY HOME! Life is a
risk. Crossing the street is dangerous. Flying in an airplane is dangerous.
And going out on the water when you weren't born with gills and flippers is
dangerous. We can't protect ourselves from everything. But we can do
something about bad decision-making. And that day is coming. US Sailig will
either become a responsive, member-oriented body again, or they will be
replaced. It has happened before in other sports and it will happen again.
A penalty right on the finish line today cost Italian yachtsman Paolo Cian
the chance to continue on into the third round robin of the Soling world
match racing championship on Port Phillip - and gave the key place to New
Zealand's Rod Davis. The on-the-water judges ruled that the Italian had
breached the racing rules as he and the New Zealander came into the finish,
boat-for-boat in the second last of seven flights. The Italian crossed the
line first, but the race committee awarded the flight to Davis who,
although beaten in the final flight, qualified to move on to the third
flight tomorrow. Davis, a former America's Cup skipper, finished with five
wins and two losses while Paolo missed the cut with three wins and four
Britain's Andrew Beadsworth sailed impressively to win six of the seven
flights while American Jeff Madrigali, the bronze medallist in the match
racing finals at the Atlanta Olympics, sailed out of Savannah, again proved
his skill, with a 5-2 score in 12-18 knot south-westerly breeze and lumpy
sea. Australia's Cameron Miles won only one flight, beating Sweden's Hans
Wallen in the seventh flight. Wallen also qualified to move on, scoring 4-3
Also eliminated were France's Philippe Presti who finished 3-4 and Sergey
Pichugin from the Ukraine, who failed to win one flight. Tomorrow, Davis,
Madrigali, Beadsworth and Wallen will race against the top four ranked
skippers Denmark's Stig Westergaard, Atlanta gold medallist and world
champion Jochen Schuemann from Germany, Norway's Herman Horn Johannessen,
and Roy Heiner from The Netherlands.
The four top skippers and their crews will be then sail semi-finals on
Thursday and the final for the prestigious Infanta Dona Cristina Trophy on
Event website: http://99worlds.org
The Cruising Club of America has created a special "Fifty-year Medallion"
as a tribute to a unique group of yachtsmen: its 29 members who were
elected to membership over 50 years ago. Led by noted yacht designer Olin
J. Stephens II, who became a member 70 years ago, on March 25, 1929, the
distinguished group will be presented medallions by Commodore James C.
Pitney at the Club's annual winter meeting at the New York Yacht Club on
January 26, 1999.
"It will be a rare and unusual privilege to be in the company of sailors of
the stature of this group," said Commodore Pitney, "including as it does
the most notable yacht designer of the modern era, a three-time Bermuda
Race winner, America's Cup defender, many circumnavigators, transoceanic
passagemakers, and others of whose achievements The Cruising Club of
America, and in fact the entire yachting community, can be justly proud."
Members of the group, listed in order of their dates of election, are:Olin
J. Stephens, II, Hanover NH (March 25 1929); Robert L. Garland, Oyster Bay,
NY (February 27, 1930); Edward R. Greeff, Mill Neck NY (February 2 1932);
Samuel C. Loveland, Jr., Chestertown MD (January 19 1935); Stuart T.
Hotchkiss, Madison CT (February 19 1935); Albert Pratt, Osterville MA
(February 19 1935); Dennis Puleston, Brookhaven NY (May 28, 1936); Bruce
Morrison, Englewood FL (November 23 1936); Roderick O. Williams, New Canaan
CT (May 8 1937); Andrew Hepburn, Marion MA (May 8 1937); William N. Mills,
San Francisco CA (November 4 1937); Leverett B. Davis, Damariscotta ME (May
11 1939); William Boyd, Jr., Sewickley PA, (May 11 1939); Albert P. Gould,
Groton MA (July 13 1939); William M. Stiger, Oyster Bay NY (March 4 1940);
G.W. Mefferd, Palm City FL (January 15 1941); Forbes Morse, Pound Ridge, NY
(May 15 1941); Frederick Sturges III, Old Lyme CT (December 10 1942);
William B. Dodge. Mystic CT, (December 10 1942); Robert N. Bavier, Jr.,
Charleston SC, (June 7 1943); H. Lee Platt, Christiansted, St. Croix USVI
(January 13 1944); Worth Loomis, Hartford CT (April 22 1944); Alexander K.
Murphy, Branford CT (June 18 1946); Edward B. Watson, Noank CT (November 11
1946); Carleton Mitchell, Key Biscayne FL (January 9 1947); Thomas H.
Closs, Sr., Annapolis MD, (November 6 1947); Renwick E. Case, Rowayton CT,
(April 8 1948); Richard Maxwell, Greenwich CT (January 7 1949); Henry S.
Noble, New Canaan CT (January 7 1949).
Founded in the winter of 1921-22 by a group of yachtsmen interested in
cruising under sail and in the development of the cruising type of yacht,
The Cruising Club of America is today comprised of over 1,100 men and
women, international sailors, who are elected to membership based on their
demonstrated competence and experience in cruising long distances offshore.
The Cruising Club of America maintains two websites:www.cruisingclub.org
REPORT FROM MELBOURNE - by Whitney Connor & Elizabeth Kratzig
We just finished the 1999 470 World Championship held on Port Philip Bay in
Melbourne, Australia. The regatta was 7 days long and the racing
conditions were great! The wind was usually moderate for the first race
and then a strong seabreeze of 15 to 25 knots filled in for the second and
third races of the day. As the breeze built each afternoon so did the
waves. Some of the days the waves grew to be so big that the whole boat
would lift out of the water as we went up and over the waves. The heavy
winds and big waves made for a fun and exciting week of racing.
This World Championship was an important event because it determined which
countries can send boats to the 2000 Olympic Games. Only eighteen
countries are allowed to compete in the Women's 470 division. Six
countries qualified at the 1998 World Championships. This 1999 Worlds
determined the next six country participants, and the 2000 World
Championship in Hungary will decide which countries have the final six
spots. By placing 11th in the regatta, we qualified the USA to send a boat
to compete in the 470 division of the 2000 Olympic Games.
We were happy with our performance in the 1999 World Championships. Not
only did we tie for 10th place, but we were the top American in the
regatta. Most importantly, however, we sailed well enough to qualify the
USA for a spot in the 2000 Olympic Games. We have made huge improvements
over the last 6 months, which is easily seen when you compare our 1998
Worlds finish of 31st with this years tie for 10th! This is certainly the
best finish we have had yet in a 470 World Championship. Our finishes at
the Worlds and the regattas we sailed in Sydney in December should move us
into the top 10 of the International 470 Women's Rankings. We are now
excited to go home to the USA and practice hard so that when we race
against these teams in Europe this spring we will be able to beat even more
THE CURMUDGEON'S POLICIES
Sarcasm is just one more service we offer.